Comcast is the largest internet provider in the United States, serving their customers under the “Xfinity” brand. The provider serves nearly half of the internet users in the U.S., with 30.3 million users as of January 2019.
While Comcast’s Xfinity may be the largest internet provider in the U.S., they are certainly not the best loved. Comcast has been known to throttle the connection speeds of users who share files via peer-to-peer file-sharing networks or access streaming services – most famously, Netflix.
Xfinity has also been known to occasionally “accidentally” block certain websites and services via their “protected browsing” feature, including such popular sites as PayPal and Steam.
The provider has been a driving force behind efforts to combat net neutrality. Unfortunately, the FCC has been receptive to such lobbying, repealing the Open Internet Order put in place by the Obama administration.
Comcast Xfinity also tracks its customers’ online activities, collecting the information and selling it to third parties, such as advertisers and data brokers.
Happily, online users have a tool available to help them avoid Xfinity’s throttling, blocking and tracking tendencies: a Virtual Private Network (VPN).
A VPN encrypts your traffic, preventing Xfinity or anyone else from monitoring your internet activities. This not only prevents the ISP from tracking your online activities, it also prevents them from throttling your connection speeds, no matter what online activity you are engaging in.
A VPN also offers the ability to open access to websites, services and content that you might not normally have access to in your region.
Not only that, but a quality VPN provider will also help protect your privacy by keeping no logs connected to your online travels, ensuring there is no evidence of your activities, no matter what online hobby you might engage in.
Best VPNs for Comcast Xfinity
I put all of my favorite VPN providers through extensive testing, and the results proved that these 6 VPNs worked best for Comcast Xfinity users:
- ExpressVPN: Delivers fast connection speeds and imposes no bandwidth limitations or data caps. Offers top-notch unblocking power for Netflix and other streaming sites and provides excellent security and privacy protections.
- NordVPN: Low-priced provider that delivers speedy connections that are well-protected by 256-bit encryption. Global server coverage could be better, but still offers a goodly amount of unblocking power.
- Surfshark: This fast-growing provider delivers unlimited simultaneous connections that connect to Netflix, BBC iPlayer and other streaming services. The
- CyberGhost: A great option for first-time VPN users looking for champagne service on a beer-bottle budget. Easy-to-use apps and decent Netflix-unblocking power.
- VyprVPN: Good native app support, and the apps are easy to use. Owns and operates its servers, keeping your data away from third parties. Their swift connections aren’t limited by data caps or bandwidth-squeezing.
- PrivateVPN: Excellent option for streaming lovers, with plenty of speed and the ability to unblock Netflix and other streaming services. Good focus on security and privacy protection.
I evaluated and ranked the top Xfinity VPNs by the following criteria:
- Keeps no logs of users’ online activities
- Fast connection speeds
- Unlimited bandwidth with no data caps
- Works well with Netflix and other geo-blocked content
- Allows BitTorrent P2P file-sharing activity
Here’s my list of the top 6 VPNs for use with Xfinity.
ExpressVPN is the #1 VPN to improve your Comcast Xfinity experience.
Other VPN providers should really follow this provider’s example when it comes to privacy protections. ExpressVPN keeps no logs of any kind. A Bitcoin payment option means your subscription payment information can be kept anonymous.
Fast connections are the rule with this provider, with speeds that are more than up to streaming video, downloading files or competing in online gaming arenas. ExpressVPN also has no bandwidth limitations or data caps whatsoever.
With 3,000+ VPN servers in 94 countries, ExpressVPN has most of the world covered, opening up access to geographically-blocked content, including shows and movies from Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video and other services.
Some VPN providers either don’t allow peer-to-peer file sharing while on their networks or limit the activity to a few select servers. ExpressVPN allows P2P file sharing on all of their servers.
All of the provider’s connections are protected by military-grade encryption, and desktop apps provide kill switch protections.
ExpressVPN provides apps for all of the most popular device platforms, including Windows, Android, macOS, iOS, Linux, Amazon Fire TV, Chromebook and others. Extensions are available for the Chrome, Firefox and Safari browsers.
ExpressVPN allows 5 simultaneous connections on a single username. You can protect all of the connected devices in your home or office via your ExpressVPN-compatible router.
- Optimal privacy protections
- Perfect for video streaming, gaming and more
- Excellent global server coverage
- Unlimited bandwidth, no data caps
- Works well with Netflix and other streaming services
- More expensive than many other providers
Read our full review of ExpressVPN.
NordVPN finished at a strong 2nd place thanks to its speedy connections, top-notch privacy protections and good access to Netflix and other streaming services.
This Panama-based provider’s privacy protections are some of the best in the VPN business, as it keeps no logs of your online activities while connected to its servers and accepts the privacy-protecting Bitcoin as payment.
Connection speeds shouldn’t be a concern for NordVPN users, as the service provides connections that are well up to music and video streaming, file sharing and gaming. Plus, there are no bandwidth limitations or data caps to worry about.
NordVPN’s Netflix access is reliable but is limited to the U.S., Canada, Japan, the U.K., the Netherlands, France and Italy. U.S. Hulu and Amazon Prime Video streams are also available while using this VPN.
NordVPN has nearly 5,200 servers stationed in nearly 60 countries at the time of this article, providing good, if not excellent, access to geo-blocked content.
NordVPN allows peer-to-peer file sharing via BitTorrent on over 1,500 of its servers, so file sharing activities will be kept incognito.
NordVPN likely has all of your connected devices covered, as it provides native apps for all of the most popular device platforms. These include Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, Linux and Android TV. Browser extensions are available to protect your Chrome and Firefox browsing sessions.
All of the apps protect your connection with 256-bit encryption. Kill switch protection is also available.
Up to 6 devices can connect to NordVPN servers at once. If you need more, you can take advantage of the provider’s compatibility with numerous makes and models of routers.
- Speedy connections for streaming, gaming and more
- Good global server coverage
- Reasonably priced
- 6 simultaneous connections
- Selecting a specific server city is impossible
BEST FOR BUDGET:NordVPN is an excellent option for the VPN user looking for a high level of service for a low price. The provider delivers speedy connections. Plus, their comprehensive app support has your devices covered. A 30-day money-back guarantee is available.
Read our full review of NordVPN.
My 3rd-place provider offers some of the best online security and privacy protections in the VPN business. The provider protects your online activities with military-grade encryption, a kill switch and DNS leak prevention.
Ad and tracker blocking, as well as phishing and malware protection, are also available. A MultiHop option allows users to route their internet connection through two VPN servers, providing double protection.
The provider does a top-notch job of ramming through Comcast Xfinity roadblocks. It also does an excellent job of hiding P2P file sharing and other “unapproved” activities.
The provider’s global server network may not be as impressive as some of its competitors’ networks, but it is steadily improving. A server network of 1,700+ servers located in 60+ countries includes servers stationed in 22+ cities in the United States. The network provides reliable access to Netflix, Hulu and other streaming services.
Privacy isn’t an issue thanks to the provider never saving any users’ logs on their servers, and their acceptance of various forms of cryptocurrency as payment for subscriptions.
If your ISP-provided download speeds can handle streaming, you won’t see any problems when using Surfshark. HD video, online gaming and file sharing are all handled readily by the provider’s no-data-caps and no-bandwidth-throttling connections.
Surfshark offers native app support for most popular device platforms, including the iOS, Android, Linux, Windows, macOS and Fire TV platforms. Chrome and Firefox browser extensions are available, as is extensive router compatibility.
Surfshark’s unlimited concurrent connections allowance provides connection protection and enhancement for an entire family or other large group of streamers to protect their online activities.
- Servers provide avoidance of Comcast Xfinity roadblocks
- Unlimited concurrent connections
- Comprehensive online security and privacy protection
- Global server coverage is slightly lacking, but expanding
- Single month subscription fee is a bit expensive
PERFECT FOR LARGE GROUPS OF USERS:If you’re looking for VPN protection for multiple online users in your family or business, take a closer look at Surfshark. Fast, well-protected connections make this provider a great choice for all online activities. A 30-day money-back guarantee is available.
Read my full review of Surfshark.
CyberGhost is an easy-to-use VPN provider. Its simple yet powerful apps make it the 3rd-best choice for Comcast Xfinity and the best choice for first-time VPN users.
CyberGhost’s privacy protections are industry-standard, keeping no records of any of your activities while connected to their service. Plus, you’ll never have to worry about your payment info being exposed thanks to the Bitcoin payment option.
This provider’s above-average connection speeds and lack of data caps or bandwidth limitations make it a good option for new users who are looking for a way to protect their streaming, gaming or other web activities.
CyberGhost offers access to geo-restricted Netflix content, but only in the United States and the United Kingdom. Hulu and Amazon Prime geo-blocked streams are also accessible using this provider.
CyberGhost’s global server coverage is somewhat average, tallying in at 3,700+ servers in 60 countries. While this provider does allow P2P file sharing, the activity is only allowed on select servers. Look for a server location without an “!” next to it, and you should be good to go.
Keeping your connected devices protected should not be an issue with CyberGhost, as apps for most popular platforms are readily available. Windows, macOS, iOS and Android are protected, as well as Amazon Fire TV and Android TV devices. Chrome and Firefox users can protect their browsing with extensions.
While CyberGhost allows a generous 7 concurrent connections via a single login, you can expand your device protection even more by making use of the service’s excellent router compatibility.
- Top-notch app compatibility
- First-time VPN users will appreciate the ease of use
- Speedy, streaming-ready connections
- Top-notch security and privacy protections
- P2P activity limited to select few servers
BEST FOR FIRST-TIMERS:CyberGhost is the best VPN on this list for first-time VPN users. One-click protection makes it easy to encrypt your connection, and the provider’s above-average connection speeds and more-than-adequate app support have you covered. A 45-day money-back guarantee is available.
Read our full review of CyberGhost.
VyprVPN took the 4th spot on this list thanks to the dependable, fast connections that the service’s self-owned and -operated servers provide.
This provider keeps no logs of any kind, so no one can connect your online activities to your account. Sadly, there aren’t any anonymous payment options, such as Bitcoin, available to protect your payment info.
VyprVPN delivers connections more than up to your streaming, file transfer and gaming needs, and you’ll never have to worry about data caps or bandwidth limitations. Streaming video from providers like Netflix, Hulu and Amazon are all available.
VyprVPN has 700+ self-owned and -operated servers located in over 70 countries. Owning and operating their servers means no third parties have access to your personal data and online activities. Plus, they can react more quickly in case there are any problems.
That server count makes it likely that you’ll have no problems in accessing your favorite geo-blocked streaming or gaming materials. All of those servers allow BitTorrent file-sharing activity, so share away!
Native app support is strong with this one, with apps for macOS, Windows, iOS, Amazon Fire TV, Android and Android TV all making the roll call.
The service is also compatible with DD-WRT, OpenWRT and ASUSWRT routers, making up somewhat for the provider’s low simultaneous connection limit of 3.
- Proprietary servers in 70+ countries
- No data caps or bandwidth limits
- Excellent app and router support
- Takes a bigger chunk out of your billfold than many other VPNs
- Simultaneous connection limit of 3
OWNS ITS SERVERS:VyprVPN owns and operates its servers, adding another protective layer for your personal data and online activities. VyperVPN’s connections are HD-streaming-capable and protected by military-grade encryption. A 30-day money-back guarantee is available.
Read our full review of VyprVPN.
PrivateVPN made it into this top 5 list thanks to its excellent connection speeds, top-notch privacy protections and record of providing reliable unblocking of video streaming services.
PrivateVPN reliably protects your online identity, saving no user logs of any kind and accepting Bitcoin to keep your payment information anonymous.
The provider delivers speedy, well-protected connections, which can deliver reliable download speeds for streaming, gaming and other connection-intensive online activities. No data caps or bandwidth restrictions are ever imposed.
Geographically-blocked streaming services such as Netflix aren’t out of reach for this provider, as it does a reliable job of ramming through geo-controlled content roadblocks.
While PrivateVPN’s server count is limited to a mere 150 or so servers, they are well spread out around the globe, settling in at 60 countries.
The provider is P2P-file-sharing-friendly, but you’ll want to connect to their servers located in Sweden to get the best performance for your file transfers.
Native app support from this service is limited to the most popular platforms: macOS, iOS, Windows and Android. Kodi users will enjoy the PrivateVPN add-on, allowing their viewing sessions to be protected.
PrivateVPN offers a somewhat-generous 6 simultaneous connections on a single login, so large families (other than the Brady Bunch) should be well covered.
- Great privacy protections
- Connection speeds up to par
- Up to 6 simultaneous connections
- Skimpy server numbers
- Multi-platform support somewhat lacking compared to others
GREAT CONNECTION SPEEDS:PrivateVPN delivers great connection speeds on up to 6 devices at once, making it a great option for large groups of users. The provider’s server count is low, but the country coverage is average for the industry. A 30-day money-back guarantee is available.
How to Use a VPN With Comcast Xfinity
If you’re searching for a way to improve your Xfinity online experience, do the following:
- Subscribe to the VPN provider that best meets your needs.
- Download and install the VPN app(s) for your device(s).
- Log into the VPN application.
- Select and connect to a VPN server.
- Enjoy your online activities, free of Xfinity’s restrictions.
Is a Free VPN a Good Option for Use With Comcast Xfinity?
While you may be able to get away with using a free VPN provider with your Xfinity internet connection, I’m certain you wouldn’t be satisfied with the experience.
Remember that one of the reasons you want to use a VPN with your Xfinity connection is to avoid throttling and bandwidth limitations. Well, some free VPNs impose similar limitations on their users, limiting both bandwidth and the amount of data you can use while connected to their servers.
Free VPN providers may also place your device in a queue, where you’ll be required to wait until a slot opens up on a server.
Once you’re allowed to connect, your server options could be limited, or you may be automatically connected to a server, with no opportunity to select a particular city or country.
You might be surprised to learn that many “free” providers aren’t really free, they actually cost you dearly, mostly with your privacy. Many “free” VPNs make money by logging your online usage and selling that valuable info to advertisers and other nosy parties.
Other VPNs might even inject tracking cookies and ads into your browsing sessions. Just what you need, eh? More ads in your browser.
Xfinity already collects enough information about your online habits – you don’t need a VPN tracking your antics, too. Right? I believe you should avoid free VPNs like the plague.
Comcast Xfinity VPN FAQs
Can A VPN Help Me Avoid Comcast Xfinity Monthly Data Caps?
Unfortunately, while a VPN can help you prevent Comcast Xfinity from throttling your connection speeds, it cannot help you with data caps. A data cap is based on the amount of data you use during a billing period.
Why Does Comcast Xfinity Throttle Some Users' Connection Speeds?
Comcast Xfinity has in the past throttled their users' connection speeds for using their internet connection to stream from certain streaming services or for engaging in peer-to-peer file sharing. A VPN can prevent the ISP from monitoring your activities, thereby preventing them from throttling your connection because of what you're doing online.
Can I Use a VPN-Enabled Router With Comcast Xfinity?
Yes. While Comcast Xfinity offers combination cable modem/router devices, it's best to use a separate router that is compatible with your VPN service. Contact your VPN provider's customer support department for information on which brand and model routers the service is compatible with.
Comcast Xfinity subscribers looking for a way to enhance and protect their internet access would do well to investigate the security and privacy protections that a Virtual Private Network offers, especially one like my #1 VPN for Comcast Xfinity, ExpressVPN.
For more information or to subscribe, visit the ExpressVPN website.